The book's checklist
- Lower cost of livingEveryday prices run 12.6% above the U.S. average in the New York-Newark-Jersey City metro area.
- More house for the moneyThe Census survey didn't reach enough homes in Water Mill to say.
- A safer neighborhoodThe FBI doesn't publish crime figures for unincorporated communities. Call the county sheriff's office (or the town or township police, where there is one) and ask what calls they get most.
- Schools in town1 public school.
- A hospital close byPeconic Bay Medical Center in Riverhead, about 17 miles away, has the nearest emergency room.
- Within reach of a big cityBridgeport is about 48 miles away as the crow flies. The book suggests staying within about 60 miles if you'll miss big-city sports, concerts and theater.
A check means the town meets the book's rule of thumb; an empty box is something to weigh; a question mark means too little data.
Water Mill meets 3 of the 4 rules of thumb we have data for. Frank and Dave's free book explains how to weigh the rest for your family.
What kind of town
Water Mill is part of the built-up area of the New York-Jersey City-Newark urban area (Census Bureau, 2020 urban areas). We include places like this under 20,000 people because some still feel like small towns, but daily life here can be closer to the suburbs than to the towns Frank and Dave's book describes. Weigh it against towns farther out.
Tourist town. About 1 in 2 homes is a vacation or seasonal home, a sign of a visitor economy. More restaurants, shops and weekend events than locals alone could support, with the small-town basics intact.
The book sorts small towns into six types. These labels come only from the numbers; take the quiz to see which type fits your family.
Sources: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024; Census Bureau Gazetteer, 2025.
For a lifetime
Homes and money
- Typical home value, as owners valued them in 2020-2024
- $2,000,000 or moreU.S.: $332,700; New York: $423,800
- Home prices since then
- Up 23%Suffolk County, 2022 to 2025
- Typical rent, with utilities
- $3,200 a monthU.S.: $1,413; New York: $1,621
- Homes owned by the people living in them
- 94%U.S.: 65%; New York: 54%
- Typical property tax bill
- $10,000 or more a yearNew York: $6,582
- Homes built before 1940
- 10%U.S.: 12%; New York: 30%
- Homes built since 2010
- 14%U.S.: 11%; New York: 6%
- Typical year homes were built
- 1995U.S.: 1980; New York: 1959
- Vacation and seasonal homes
- 50%U.S.: 3%; New York: 4%
- Everyday prices
- 112.6U.S. average = 100 (the New York-Newark-Jersey City metro area)
- Housing costs (U.S. average = 100)
- 148.6New York area
County prices have moved up 23% since 2022. Check current listings before you budget.
Sources: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024; FHFA county house price index; BEA Regional Price Parities, 2024.
Read next: How to buy a house in a small town
The people
- Population, 2020-2024 Census survey
- 2,764The Census Bureau makes yearly estimates only for incorporated towns
- People per square mile
- 261Mixes the 2020-2024 Census survey count with 10.6 square miles of land (2025 Gazetteer)
- Median age
- 54.9 yearsU.S.: 38.9; New York: 39.8
- Age 65 and older
- 23%U.S.: 17%; New York: 18%
- Under 18
- 12%U.S.: 22%; New York: 20%
- Adults with a bachelor's degree or more
- 73%U.S.: 36%; New York: 40%
- Moved here from another county or state in the past year
- 12%U.S.: 6%; New York: 5%
Sources: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024; Census Bureau Gazetteer, 2025.
Work
- Unemployment rate
- 6%U.S.: 5%; New York: 6%
- Below the poverty line
- 4%U.S.: 12%; New York: 14%
Source: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024.
Read next: How to keep working when you move to a small town
Health care
Nearest emergency room: Peconic Bay Medical Center, Riverhead, NY, about 17 miles away. It's a general hospital. Medicare gives it 2 of 5 stars.
Look up doctors, clinics and the hospitals themselves on Medicare's Care Compare. Ask where the most serious cases are sent.
Source: Medicare hospital data.
Read next: Retiring to a small town on a fixed income: a planning checklist
Schools
1 public school in Water Mill, run by Southampton Union Free School District.
See each school on the federal school search, then check test scores and graduation rates on New York's school report card.
Source: NCES Common Core of Data, 2023-24.
Read next: How to choose a school when you move to a small town
Weather
- January average low
- 23°F
- July average high
- 81°F
- Days 90°F or hotter
- 5 a year
- Nights at or below freezing
- 106 a year
- Rain and melted snow
- 49.8 inches a year
- Snow
- 27 inches a year
- Elevation
- 21 feet
Weather station: Bridgehampton (3 miles away). Averages for 1991 to 2020.
Sources: NOAA climate normals, 1991-2020; USGS elevation data.
Getting around
Straight-line miles. The road is always longer, and as the book says, an interstate at 70 is a different trip from a farm road at 45. Check the real drive: Peconic Bay Medical Center, New Haven, Bridgeport.
Suffolk County is in a metro area of 1 million people or more (USDA rural-urban code 1, on a scale where 1 is the biggest metro areas and 9 the most rural counties).
For a day
1 place on the National Register of Historic Places: the Water Mill.
National Park Service sites within about an hour:
- Fire Island National Seashore23 miles
- Sagamore Hill National Historic Site60 miles
Sources: National Register of Historic Places; National Park Service.
Read about Water Mill's history on Wikipedia.
Know Water Mill? Tell us what a visitor shouldn't miss: mainstreet@smalltownguide.com.
Nearby
Straight-line miles.
Small towns
- North Sea, NY6,500 people, 3 miles
- Noyack, NY4,800 people, 4 miles
- Southampton, NY4,700 people, 4 miles
- Sagaponack, NY752 people, 4 miles
- Shinnecock Hills, NY2,500 people, 6 miles
- Sag Harbor, NY2,800 people, 6 miles
- North Haven, NY1,220 people, 7 miles
- East Hampton, NY1,550 people, 8 miles
Other towns in Suffolk County
- Riverhead, NY14,900 people, 17 miles
- Huntington, NY19,900 people, 55 miles
- Melville, NY19,700 people, 56 miles
- East Northport, NY19,700 people, 51 miles
- Holtsville, NY19,300 people, 37 miles
- Ronkonkoma, NY18,700 people, 41 miles
- Lake Ronkonkoma, NY18,200 people, 40 miles
- North Babylon, NY18,000 people, 53 miles
- Islip, NY17,400 people, 47 miles
- Mastic Beach, NY16,700 people, 28 miles
- Kings Park, NY16,500 people, 47 miles
- Farmingville, NY16,200 people, 36 miles
See every town in Suffolk County
Unincorporated places nearby
Communities under 2,500 people, too small for a page of their own.
- Bridgehampton, NY (unincorporated)1,531 people, 3 miles
- Tuckahoe, NY (unincorporated)1,249 people, 5 miles
- Wainscott, NY (unincorporated)612 people, 5 miles
- New Suffolk, NY (unincorporated)298 people, 8 miles
- Shelter Island Heights, NY (unincorporated)1,230 people, 9 miles
- Shelter Island, NY (unincorporated)2,125 people, 10 miles
- Peconic, NY (unincorporated)848 people, 10 miles
- Laurel, NY (unincorporated)1,360 people, 11 miles
Sources (12)
Show all 12 sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates (Vintage 2025)
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates
- U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Regional Price Parities, 2024
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Hospital General Information
- National Center for Education Statistics, Common Core of Data, 2023-24 (via the Urban Institute Education Data Portal)
- NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information, U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020
- U.S. Geological Survey, 3D Elevation Program
- National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places listings
- National Park Service, park unit boundaries
- USDA Economic Research Service, Rural-Urban Continuum Codes, 2023
- Federal Housing Finance Agency, House Price Index for counties (all transactions)
- U.S. Census Bureau, 2025 Gazetteer files and 2020 urban areas
Census survey figures are estimates with a margin of error; we leave out any figure whose margin is too wide to be useful. Data last gathered November 19, 2026. See something wrong? Write to mainstreet@smalltownguide.com.